(18)
bring happiness to his daughter's life and about the Prophet's reckoning Ali an executer of non-honorable jobs. Although he authorized him to cut off necks, he avoided entrusting leadership positions to him ...Yet, worse than this was when a quarrel occurred between Ali and Fatima regarding their enmity to the Prophet's wives, Fatima would sorrowfully blame her Father for not siding with his daughters..." The writer of the above mentioned book added many other such fables which are nothing but crimes against history which, the writer marred the pages of his book with. Sheikh Amini (may Allah be pleased with him) wrote in answer to this Christian's fabrications: "I do not blame the author (may Allah amputate his ears) despite the fact that he fabricated many false stories; because he is from a people who resent Islam, and good deeds are not expected from him; for both his obvious and hidden shortcomings are revealed in his book. Rather all the blame lies on the translator who committed a massive crime against Islam and the Arabs-while considering himself one of them- but indeed: "Birds of a feather flock together." It is clear that all, which was written in the book from these different fables and fabricated lies are nothing but heedless words that contradict the true historical facts, and oppose what the Islamic Ummah collectively agree upon in accordance to what they heard from the Holy Prophet (P.B.U.H.). Do the rumors spread by this book against Fatima correspond with her Father's (P.B.U.H.) saying: "Fatima is a human huri, whenever I long for paradise I kiss her."?[1] or: "My daughter Fatima is a human huri."[2] or: "Fatima is the true splendor." [3] |
(19)
or with Anas Ibn Malik's Mother saying: "Fatima was like a moon on its full night, or the sun covered with no clouds. She was white with a touch of rose color on her face, her hair was black and she had the beautiful features of the Messenger of Allah (P.B.U.H.)" [4] Her given name "Zahra" reveals the truth of the matter. Besides, do the writers' arbitrary false judgements against Fatima's intelligence and noble manners conform to her Mother's (The Mother of the Faithful, Khadija, may Allah be pleased with her) saying: "Fatima used to speak when she was in her Mother's womb; when she was born, she fell on the ground in a prostrating position with her finger raised."[5] or Aisha's saying: "I have not seen a person more similar to the Prophet's appearance, conduct, guidance and speech whether sitting or standing than Fatima. When she enters, the Messenger of Allah stands up, kisses and welcomes her, then takes her hand and asks her to sit in his place." [6] Also in Bihaqi's quotation in Sunah vol. 7, p. 101, Aisha said: "I have not seen anyone more similar to the Messenger of Allah's habit of speech and dialogue than Fatima... " As for the writer's awkward description of Imam Ali (A.S.) that Fatima considered him homely and gloomy, the least that can be said is that it does not consist with what has been mentioned regarding his handsome features: He had a splendid face, as if it was the full moon, his neck appeared like a silver jug, [7] and he was cheerful,[8] whenever he smiled, his teeth appeared to be organized pearls. [9] Neither does that rude description consist with Abu
|
(20)
Al-Aswad Duali's poetic saying that whenever he came face to face with Ali (A.S.), he felt as if he was facing the full moon. Does your clear conscience agree with the Orientalist's slandering of Ali (A.S.) as being "limp and irresolute"? While it is he that is the well - known adventurer and invincible knight who participated in many battles and wars. Is not Ali the one who relieved the Messenger of Allah (P.B.U.H.) from many inflictions and calamities which had clouded his life since he spoke openly of the righteous religion until he lay down on his death bed, and sacrificed himself for the great Prophet until he entered his last dwell? Is Ali not the only soldier of Islam in whose name the following verses have been revealed? "Do ye make the giving of drink to pilgrims, or the maintenance of The Sacred Mosque, equal to (the pious service of) those who believe in Allah and the Last Day, and strive in the cause of Allah?"(9:19) and: "There is the type of man who gives his life to earn the pleasure of Allah." (2: 207) Hence, when did Ali stop competing with men, and defending the Prophet so that he deserved to be described as limp and irresolute?! But indeed false claims never end. Can it be conceived that the Prince of The Faithful (A.S.) acted in such an atrocious manner with his noble wife, while the Prophet says to him "Your conduct and looks are similar to mine, and you are from the same tree from which I came." [10] While the Prophet declared that Ali was the best man of his nation, for he was the most patient and best mannered one of them all, and says: |
(21)
"Ali is the best of my nation, most knowledgeable and most patient from among them"[11] Would Ali behave in such a manner when he heard the Prophet (P.B.U.H.) say to Fatima? "I gave you in marriage to the first one to adhere to Islam from my nation, he is also the most knowledgeable and most patient among them?" [12] and: "I gave you in marriage to the first Muslim and best mannered man." [13] Would the Prophet (P.B.U.H.) say all of this about Ali, while he behaved cruelly with Fatima? Surely the croaks fabricate many a falsehood; for Ali was exactly the honest and truthful one Messenger of Allah (P.B.U.H.) said about. Can you accept the slanderous accusation made by the writer (how evil has he spoken) that Ali physically abused Fatima, the Prophet's daughter?! While you know that Ali is that obedient believer of the Messenger who heard the Prophet say to Fatima: "Surely Allah is angered when you are angered, and is pleased at your pleasure."[14] He also said to Fatima while holding her hand: "He who knows this, knows her, and he who does not know her; she is part of me, she is my heart and my spirit which is in my side, thus he who harms her harms me." [15] He also said: "Fatima is part of me, that which annoys her annoys me, and harms me that which harms her." [16] and: "Fatima is part of me, he who angers her angers me."[17] Did the Prophet limit his praise of Ali to his precedence in
|
(22)
adhering to Islam? Did he endeavor to keep this a secret by only informing his daughter in order to satisfy her?! Had this been true!! Then why did he (P.B.U.H.) take Ali's hand and raise it publicly and announce: "He was the first to believe in me, and he will be the first to shake my hand on the Day of Rising!?" He also informed his companions that: "The first among you to appear at my domain (reservoir), is he who was the first among you to follow Islam Ali Ibn Abu Talib." Could this so-called secret remain hidden from the companions and those that followed them in adhering to the truth; while they insisted on extolling him as the following group did: Salman the Persian, Anas Ibn Malik, Zaid Ibn Arqam, Abdullah Ibn Hijl, Hashim Ibn Utba, Malik Al-Ashtar, Abdullah Ibn Hashim, Abu Amrah Adi Ibn Hatem, Abu Rafe, Buraidah, Jundub Ibn Zuhair, and Um Al-Khair Ibnat Al-Harash.[18] And, does claiming that the Prophet (P.B.U.H.) paid little attention to Ali consist with the Quranic declaration that he (Ali (A.S.)) is the same as the Prophet's self?! Or that it (Quran) made the reward for the divine message the love of Ali (A.S.)?... Or with that which was narrated in the story of the roasted bird-which is mentioned in the Sahihs and Musnads-when the Prophet said: "O Allah, bring the most beloved creature to You so that he may eat with me." or when he said to Aisha:
"Surely Ali is the most beloved of all men and the most precious to me. Therefore, recognize his rights, and pay tribute to him."[19] And: "The most beloved of all men to me is Ali."[20] And: |
(23)
"Ali is the best of those whom I leave behind me (after death)."[21] And: "The best of your men is Ali Ibn Abu Talib, and the best of your women is Fatima Bint Muhammad."[22] And: "Ali is the best of mankind, and he who denies (this) is an infidel."[23] And: "He who does not say that Ali is the best of mankind is surely an infidel."[24] And in Banner's narration where it has been unanimously agreed that he (P.B.U.H.) said: "Tomorrow I will hand over the banner to a man whom Allah and His Messenger love, and who loves Allah and His Messenger." And: "Ali to me is like my head to my body."[25] And: "Ali to me is like I am to my Lord."[26] And: "Ali is the most beloved to me, and the most beloved to Allah."[27] He (P.B.U.H.) also said to Ali: "I am from you, and you are from me; or you are from me and I am from you."[28] And: 'Ali is from me and I am from him; he is the guardian (wali) of every believer after me."[29] And: -In the narration regarding sending Ali (A.S.) to read Surah At-tawbah (Surah No. 9) to the pilgrims on which it has been unanimously agreed, he said: "No one takes it (to the pilgrims) except a man being from me
|
(24)
and I from him."[30] And: "Your flesh is my flesh, your blood is my blood, and righteousness is on your side."[31] And: "There is not a prophet who has not had a peer, and Ali is my peer."[32] Also, in a narration that Al-Hakim deemed authentic, Tabarani related to Umme Salama the following: "Whenever the Prophet of Allah was angered, no one dared to speak to him save Ali."[33] Also Aisha said: "(I declare) by Allah that I have not seen anyone more beloved to Allah 's Messenger than Ali, or a woman on earth more beloved to him than his wife (Ali's wife, Fatima)."[34] Buraida and Ubae also said: "The most beloved to the Messenger of Allah from among women is Fatima, and from among men is Ali.,,[35] And Juma Ibn Umair said: "I entered Ali's house with my Aunt, when I inquired as to who was the most beloved of all people to Allah's Messenger?! She said: Fatima. Then she was asked: And from among men? She said: her husband, ever since I met him he has been fasting and praying."[36] Furthermore, how could it be true that Allah's Messenger preferred others over Ali and paid more attention to them, while Ali was the first man chosen by Allah to follow his Messenger from among the dwellers of Earth, as he (P.B.U.H.) told Fatima in the following narration: "Surely Allah has examined the dwellers of Earth and has chosen your
Father to be a prophet, He then examined(them)and chose your husband,then He
revealed to me that I give(you to him
|
(25)
in) marriage and appointed him as my successor."[37] He (P.B.U.H.) also said to Fatima: "Surely Allah chose two men from the dwellers of Earth, one being your Father and the other your husband."[38] There are many other authentic traditions that Sheikh Amini (may Allah bless him) mentioned, refuting the false claims made by the misguided writer. Nevertheless, the harsh assaults against the family of Allah's Messenger are endless; as the situation requires, we will mention more of these narrations, if Allah wills. It is worthy to made a brief introduction, before we embark on the core of the subject. Because this book tackles the life story of a person higher than that which mankind is accustomed to, it is incumbent upon us to speak of matters, which can be considered "transcendental" for the character discussed here is an excellent genius, and the truth of this will become clear to you as you read on.
[1] Tareekh Baghdad by Khateeb Baghdadi: v.5, p.86.
[2] Al-Sawa'iq al-Muhriqa and Is'af Ar-Raghebeen: p.173.
[3] Nuzhat al-Jaliss: v.2, P222.
[4] Mustadrak al-Hakim: v.3, p.161.
[5] Sirat Al-Muwla, Dhakha'er al-Uqbi.
[6] Tirmadhi and Ibn Abdurabbeh in Eqd al-Farid: v.2, p.3.
[7] Esti'ab: v.2, p.469.
[8] Tahdheeb al-Asma Wal-Lughat.
[9] Hilyat al-Awliya: v.1, p. 84.
[10] Tareekh Baghdad: v.11, p.171.
[11] Tabari, Khateeb, Dulabi as was mentioned in Kanz al-Umal: v.6, p.153.
[12] Musnad Ahmad: v.5, p. 26, Ryadh An-Nadherah: v.2, p.194.
[13] Ryadh An-Nadherah: v.2, p.194.
[14] Mustadrak al-Hakim: v.3, p.154., Tadhkirat al-Bast: p.175., Maqtal al-Khawarazmi: v.1, p.54., Kefayat At-Talib: p.219., Kanz al-Umal: v.7, p.111., Sawiq: p.105.
[15] Al-Fusul al-Muhammad: p.150., Nuzhat Al-Majalis: v.2, p.228., Nur al-Absar: p.45.
[16] Sahih al-Bukhari, Muslim, Tirmadhi, Musnad Ahmad: v.4, p. 328., Khasaes An-Nisaee: p.35.
[17] Sahih al-Bukhari, Khasaes An-Nisaee: p.35.
[18] Most historical sources mention them
[19] Ryadh An-Nadherah: v.2, p.161., Dhakha'er al-Uqbi: p.62.
[20] In another narration of: "of my kin."
[21] Mawaqif al-Aiji: v.3, p.276, Majma' al-Zawa'ed: v.9, p.113.
[22] Tareekh Baghdad: v.4, p.392.
[23] Tareekh Baghdad, Kunuz al-Haqaeq, Hamish al-Jame' al-Saghir p.16, Kanz Al-Umal: p.159.
[24] Tareekh Baghdad: v.3, p. 192, Kanz al-Umal: v.6, p.159.
[25] Tareekh Baghdad: v.7, p.12, Sawaeq: p.75, Jame' al-Saghir by Suyuti, Nur al-Absar: p.80.
[26] As-Sirat-ul-Halabiyah: v.3, p. 391 Ryadh An-Nadherah: v.2, p.163.
[27] Tareekh Baghdad: v.1, p.160.
[28] Musnad Ahmad: v.5, p.204, Khasaes An-Nisaee: pp.36, 51.
[29] Musnad Ahmad: v.5, p.356.
[30] Khasaes An-Nisaee: p.8.
[31] Al-Mahasen Wal-Masawi: v.1, p.31.
[32] Ar-Ryadh An-Nadherah: v.2, p.164.
[33] Sawaeq: p.73, Tareekh al-Khulafa by Suyuti: p.116.
[34] Mustadrak al-Hakim: v.3, p.154, Khasaes An-Nisaee: p.29.
[35] Khasaes An-Nisaee: p.29, Mustadrak al-Hakim: v.3, p.115.
[36] Jame' At-Tirmadhi: v.2, p.227, other collective books.
[37] Tabarani, Kanz al-Ummal: v.6, p.153, Majma' al-Zawaed: v.9, p.165.
[38] Mawaqif al-Aiji: p.8.
|